Scion of Ikshvaku!
7/06/2015 09:58:00 am
After reading the Shiva trilogy I was quite impressed with Amish Tripathi and his style of writing. He keeps the plot exciting and at the same time the language he uses is easy to understand. I am not that avid a reader and prefer these kind of books where I don't have to look up my dictionary often. Coming back to the book. Shiva's trilogy was interesting and I liked it but I didn't knew much about the actual mythological backdrop on which it was based. On the contrary, I have recently finished Sita by Devdutt Pattanaik (which is also an excellent book and is a simple account of the Ramayana). That made the book even more interesting for me. Amish Tripathi has tried to be as parallel to the original story as he can but without intersecting the plots anywhere. The basic story and the twists take place as in the original but the circumstances that lead to each of these twists is novel, different and interesting. He keeps the reader engaged. There is a secret back story just as in the Shiva trilogy (which hasn't been revealed in the first book and hasn't been revealed in the first book). Working on a parallel story is difficult , be it writing a book or making a movie. One of the best example of this was Rang de Basanti. It was a cult movie and Rakesh Om Prakash Mehra did a wonderful job of setting the legendary story of the revolutionaries in the modern setup. And he did manage to keep the plot parallel to the original without deviating much. I feel Amish too has done a great job. The character traits , their origins their relations have been kept same as that of the original epic and at the same time the plots that connect these are different. The interactions in between these characters has also been given a humane touch (For eg one finds Bharat and Laxman pulling Ram's leg quite often). The book doesn't divulge into the core philosophy of Ramayana, but there are few references here and there.
All in all it's a good read. Eagerly waiting for the second part.
This is the opening quote of the book and I loved this one.
P.S.: Google Books is an awesome application if you are into ebooks and like to read them on multiple devices. It is available for iOS and android. It not only syncs your books on all your devices but also remembers the page where you left the book last time. This way you can resume reading on another device at the same point you left on the first one.
P.P.S: I know there are people who prefer actual books over ebooks.. But then ebooks give you the portability. You can read it anywhere and everywhere . Also the other advantage of google play books (or for that matter an e book reader ) is the in built dictionary for quick reference.
Dactar sahab , Report kaisa hai?
6/22/2015 06:33:00 am
It was 24th of December, I was posted in the USG section of Tata Hospital. The next patient was a 60 year patient named Mr. Joseph. He was operated for a cancer of the oral cavity, which recurred twice in his neck and he re-operated for the same. he had now developed another swelling on the opposite side of the neck. He was here for a USG guided FNAC from the new swelling (which is like taking out a small sample for examination). This looked like another recurrence and the cytologist examined and confirmed the presence of malignant cells. By this time Mr Joseph had figured out that something wasn't right (Being operated multiple times, he was quite well versed with basic medical jargon.) He asked me "Doctor , how is the report? " I explained him that it looks like another recurrence and I called out the next patient. He went outside and came back again asking if he can have a word with me. He asked me by when will the report be available, which is usually 2-3 days. By that time Tata Hospital had adopted an online system and patient could access the reports online. Once they are online, the patient gets an SMS regarding the same. So Mr. Joseph calls me outside and tells me " Beta, can you delay the report and the SMS by a few days?" That was a strange request as most of the patients want their reports to be processed asap. He continued, "I want to enjoy Christmas and New Year with my family in a happy mood. I don't know how many of them are left with me." I had tears in my eyes. I didn't know what to say to him.
That's when it hit me that we often do not realize what the patient goes through before he comes to us and while he awaits a report from us. As a radiologist we do not have a lot of actual interaction with patients, except for USG and intervention procedures. And that's the reason I like both of these. We used to have a lot of patients who come for yearly/ 6 monthly follow up USG to rule out any recurrence or metastasis. Imagine the anxiety each of these patients has as he boards his train for his follow -up check up, while he discusses his illness with his fellow inquisitive travelers (who always has a story about some distant relative/ friend who died of cancer or had a bad recurrence), while he waits outside the USG room for his appointment (where his fellow patients too often have scary stories), while we are doing the USG and once we are done with it. All this while he and his family are praying that he remains cancer free. Imagine yourself in that situation. It must be tough. And once he is done with it , his question is "Dactar sab, report kaisa hai?" (Doctor sir , how is the report?). I have seen my colleagues and my juniors often saying "Apke doctor ke pas jao, woh bataenge apko (Meet your doctor he will tell you the report) and that too in a rather insensitive tone. In fact even I have done that at times. This is especially true if the report has some positive findings. Communicating bad news to the patient in the appropriate way is an essential skill which a physican must develop. Due to the limited patient interaction we have, this is something that we lack and maybe that's one of the reason why we fail to convey reports to patients . For the patient however the anxiety gets even worse as the treating physician's OPD is usually 2-3 days later. Imagine what the patient goes through for those two days. " There must be some problem, that's why the doctor didn't tell me right away", that's the first thought that comes to his mind. And he thinks of the worst possible outcomes , only for the doctor to tell him two days later that the report is perfectly normal. It would not have taken more than few seconds to let him know that report is normal. And I have seen the sense of relief when I tell them that the report is fine. That look says it all. Even when there is a positive finding , I feel it's best to tell them in simple terms what are the implications of the same as patients assume the worst possible outcomes when they are uninformed. Imagine this is just one report. There are at least 5-6 reports he has to collect every time. These are times when "Ignorance is bliss" seems so apt (in the case of uneducated patients who do not have much idea about these as compared to the informed Internet savvy educated types)
At Tata , we get patients from all over India , it being a tertiary care center for oncology. Being the one of the top most government institute for cancer treatment, that's a place where patients get referred to from the remotest part of India. I had a patient who came all the way from Andaman and Nicobar for his follow up. He was treated case of rectal cancer. While doing his USG he told me how he had to travel for approximately 60 hrs from Andaman to Kolkata and from there a train journey for 40 hrs . And then he waited for another hour in the line before he came to me. All of this for a 5 min test (at times even less than that). And what would he feel if, at the end of these troublesome 100 odd hours he is doesn't get an answer. I told him his report was normal and he had this huge smile on his face and he thanked me and said if I ever visit Andaman , I have to come to his place.
The story is not different at Municipal hospitals. I was in the surgical ward during my second year of residency, going through patients' files, looking for that elusive " good exam case". While going through one such files , the relative told me "Dactar sab , kya hua hai inko, char din se yeh sab davai , test ho rahe hai. Par hua kya hai inko. (Doctor what has happened to him. We are being doing all these tests and taking medicines since four days but exactly what has happened to him). It was a case of duodenal ulcer , which I explained with the limited medical knowledge I had at the that time. The relative and the patient both had a smile on their face (in spite of the pain he was going through) and told me that no one had told them till now what was the exact problem since they were admitted.
Communicating with patients in the right way is not only important for the patients but that is also important for a radiologist. That way you assure that the patient stays with you. Also being a para-clinical branch we do not get the kind of satisfaction our surgical/ medical colleagues get once they treat the patient. Building a good rapport with the patient, talking to him is one of ensuring that. It's an important habit which we may realize once we start private practice. I remember one of my professors telling us this when we were caught postponing patients " Now you are refusing these patients, behaving rudely with them. Why ? Just because they are coming to your government hospital? Once you will leave this place you will crave to have such a number of patients and you will have to talk to them politely to each of them". Not only that but communicating with the patient will often save you time and help you from missing important findings. For e.g. One of my juniors came to with a patient saying he diagnosed situs inversus totalis (which is basically a condition when there is a left right inversion of organs) and he had some doubts in the rest of the scan. On asking the patient , this 60 year old lady ("maa-ji") pointing to her abdomen says " Beta yeh sab ulta hai . Idhar ka cheez udhar hai and udhar ka idhar. Aur yeh pitta ka thaili bhi nikala hai (Everything is opposite. The stuff on the right is on the left and vice versa. Plus she had her GB removed for stones) ". With a disappointed expression , my junior was like, " Yeh pehle nahi bata sakte the maa-ji" (Couldn't you have told me this before!). She would have definitely told him ,if he had asked her. After all Radiology (and medicine for that matter) is only as clinical as you want it to be.
As always there are two sides to the coin. The amount of cases each doctor sees every day in any of the government hospitals is huge. But that does not give us a reason to disrespect them in any way. May be for me its easier to say all this. Being on the para-clinical/ non-clinical side we do not have to interact with many patients. My clinical colleagues handle so many patients day in and day out and we can't expect the same from them. Or in fact they may be even better than us at handling patients, communicating them their reports. But for others who aren't as good as them , the next time a patient asks you this question " "Dactar sahab , report kaisa hai? ", please spare a minute and do let him know the same in a language that he understands.
![]() |
| This is so true!! |
P.S. Please do let me know your views in the comments.
Dil wali Delhi!!
5/12/2015 02:33:00 pm
I had to travel to Delhi for an exam and this is a short account of the same. The title is sucks and is cliché but then couldn't come up with a better title so thats what I had to settle with. Is Delhi "dil - wali " ? I am not quite sure , but is definitely full of people who like to flaunt- money, looks, attitude. Atleast thats the Delhi I saw!
Anyways I write this article to share a few travel tips which I found in handy. So to start off , the first thing you need a smart phone with decent net connectivity as traveling in Delhi can be a bit confusing. The following apps come in handy :
The easiest way to search for boarding is to do an online search and select a hotel/ hostel which suits your need. There are many cheap hostels which suit the needs of people whom roaming around in the city is a priority and can compromise on stay. Booking and Hostel World are good places to start off. I stayed at the International Youth Hostel Delhi which I found a decent and safe place to stay (Read more here : International Youth Hostel).
Once you arrive at the Airport/ Delhi railway station, you should get the Metro card which comes in really handy. For a refundable security deposit of Rs 50, you can get the card at any metro station and that will save you the long ticket queues. Also you get 10percent discount on all your tickets. If you are arriving at the airport (national or international) , the Airport Metro line is the cheapest and fastest way to get into the city. The ticket for New Delhi station is just 100 bucks which will take anything from 300 to 400 bucks by cab. For traveling within the city, metro is the cheapest option and from your station to your destination you can choose either the above cab services or the local autos/ cycle rickshaws.
I didnt get enough time to roam around but I did manage a few places. Out of the Red Fort , Jama Masjid (both of which are closeby) and Humayun's Tomb, I like the latter the most. If you are group of people it would be advisable to take a local guide as roaming around just looking at these monuments doesn't make much sense. The light show at the Red Fort is something you should not miss. Check out the timings here. Also a visit to the India gate in the night is a must.
I didnt interact much with people but the ones I did (mostly my cab drivers, hostel staff and a few random tourists whom I forced to clicking my pics) were helpful. The area around South Delhi is safe. I visited the India gate on Saturday at midnight and it was quite crowded with families having a fun time in the gardens parallel to the path leading to Rashtrapati Bhavan.
All in all it was a pleasant short stay!
P.S. It was a short trip and I didn't end up exploring much of the city and its people so its a shallow more of a technical post!
Anyways I write this article to share a few travel tips which I found in handy. So to start off , the first thing you need a smart phone with decent net connectivity as traveling in Delhi can be a bit confusing. The following apps come in handy :
- The Quintessential Google Maps : Click here to download.
- Delhi Metro Rail App. Click here to download. This is a neat app which shows the metro route with connecting stations , fare, approximate travel time and the nearest metro station. Also there is a list of places to visit with the metro station closest to each which comes in handy!
- Any of the following Taxi services , given the notoriety of the Delhi auto drivers. In fact you can use all of them one by one. Out of all the three services, I found Uber to be the most useful to get a cab immediately while Taxi for sure is good for booking cabs on a later period which is not possible using uber. Click on the name to download. Click here for free credits
The easiest way to search for boarding is to do an online search and select a hotel/ hostel which suits your need. There are many cheap hostels which suit the needs of people whom roaming around in the city is a priority and can compromise on stay. Booking and Hostel World are good places to start off. I stayed at the International Youth Hostel Delhi which I found a decent and safe place to stay (Read more here : International Youth Hostel).
Once you arrive at the Airport/ Delhi railway station, you should get the Metro card which comes in really handy. For a refundable security deposit of Rs 50, you can get the card at any metro station and that will save you the long ticket queues. Also you get 10percent discount on all your tickets. If you are arriving at the airport (national or international) , the Airport Metro line is the cheapest and fastest way to get into the city. The ticket for New Delhi station is just 100 bucks which will take anything from 300 to 400 bucks by cab. For traveling within the city, metro is the cheapest option and from your station to your destination you can choose either the above cab services or the local autos/ cycle rickshaws.
I didnt get enough time to roam around but I did manage a few places. Out of the Red Fort , Jama Masjid (both of which are closeby) and Humayun's Tomb, I like the latter the most. If you are group of people it would be advisable to take a local guide as roaming around just looking at these monuments doesn't make much sense. The light show at the Red Fort is something you should not miss. Check out the timings here. Also a visit to the India gate in the night is a must.
I didnt interact much with people but the ones I did (mostly my cab drivers, hostel staff and a few random tourists whom I forced to clicking my pics) were helpful. The area around South Delhi is safe. I visited the India gate on Saturday at midnight and it was quite crowded with families having a fun time in the gardens parallel to the path leading to Rashtrapati Bhavan.
All in all it was a pleasant short stay!
![]() |
| Old Delhi - View from the Jama Masjid minaret! |
![]() | |
|
![]() | |
|
![]() | |
|
![]() | |
|
![]() |
| Jama Masjid |
![]() |
| Meena Bazaar |
![]() |
| Humayum's Tomb |
![]() |
| Humayum;s Tomb |
![]() | |
|
![]() | |
|
![]() |
| Red Fort |
![]() |
| Red Fort |
P.S. It was a short trip and I didn't end up exploring much of the city and its people so its a shallow more of a technical post!
Jaya -An illustrated retelling of the Mahabharata
5/03/2015 04:52:00 am
" The fear of death makes animals fight for their survival. Might becomes right as only the fit survive. With strength and cunning territories are established and pecking orders enforced. Thus, the law of the jungle comes into being. Animals have no choice but to subscribe to it. Humans, however, can choose to accept, exploit or reject this law.
Thanks to our larger brain, we can imagine and create a world where we can look beyond ourselves, include others, and make everyone feel wanted and safe. We can, if we wish to, establish a society where the mighty care for the meek, and where resources are made available to help even the unfit thrive. This is dharma.
Unfortunately, imagination can also amplify fear, and make us so territorial that we withhold resources, exploit the weak and eat even when well-fed. This is adharma. If dharma enables us to outgrow the beast in us, then adharma makes us worse than animals. If dharma takes us towards divinity, then adharma fuels the demonic.
The Kauravas are stubbornly territorial before the war. The Pandavas struggle to be generous after the war. Adharma is thus an eternal temptation, while dharma is an endless work in progress that validates our humanity."
These are words from the final chapter of the book on Mahabharata by Devdutt Pattanaik and they quite aptly sum up the essence of the book. Rather I should say that of the epic called Mahabharata. First a word about the author's contribution. He has managed to present the humongous piece of literature in a concise manner. The text is lucid and he has tried to simplify the confusing tangles of relationships. He keeps providing us short revisions everytime he reintroduces a character in subsequent chapters. And this comes in handy as remembering the lineage if each character is a pain. It's like the desi Game of Thrones. Everybody is related to everybody in some complex way and there are too many bodies there to remember. Plus there is karma which keeps coming back at intervals. So by the time it hits back at someone, you are way ahead in the story and recollecting the back story is difficult. He doesn't complicate things by showing off his vocabulary and keeps the language simple (I guess that's the only reason why Chetan Bhagat has such a following in India I guess. But I doubt whether he does that to hide his vocabulary or the lack of it). Plus that was the very reason the scriptures were written in Sanskrit so that only a small portion of the population could understand them. I don't know how accurate his version is but it's a book that can give you a gist of the story in the simplest possible way. There must be many other authentic translations but then as they say Devil is in the details. It would have been difficult for me to interpret all the plots and subplots if they were presented in a more complex manner. That's just my opinion though. He has also provided these small snippets at the end of each chapter giving us interesting facts and revising those complex subplots. Also even though it's labelled as an " illustrated retelling " , the illustrations don't serve much purpose
Coming to the more important part. The epic itself. I am otherwise an atheist and was sceptical about reading the Mahabharata. But then it's nowhere close to what I thought. It's not about gods and goddess. And to contrary to belief , it's not about the Kurukshetra war. That definitely forms an important part of the story but it's not the central theme. In fact it's a medium through which the central theme is elaborated i.e. Dharma and karma. And by dharma it never means blind faith and superstitions as projected by some of the present day " dharmik babas" . It means the righteous path, what is the ideal way of life. It's not that reading this has transformed me at a spiritual level , but does make you think about so many things. Keeping aside the spiritual part of it, it makes you aware of how awesome our forefathers were. Compiling such a huge book and carrying forward it's legacy through so many generation is a tremendous task. All this in the world without computers (They didn't have any of the cloud drive technology where they could back up their data at regular intervals. One hundred thousand verses over a span of 18 chapters). All the stories have such good morals and which are quite appropriate even in the Kaliyug. Plus their knowledge of astrology and other life sciences is fascinating. During the war there are these arrows which multiply as they travel. Some postulate that the ancient Indians were aware of nuclear weapons and this was an example of a nuclear fission reaction. I think that is a bit far fetched, but you never know. The other interesting part and the one that I liked that the actual stories are way different than what they have been presented to us. Why have always been told the story of how Kunti asked Arjuna to share Draupadi equally with his brothers but then there are other reasons to it too. Here it is :
"In her past life, Draupadi had invoked Shiva and asked for a husband who was honest, a husband who was strong, a husband who was skilled, a husband who was handsome and a husband who was knowledgeable. Shiva had said, ‘You will get all five men that you want for no single man, except God. In another past life, Draupadi was Nalayani, the wife of a Rishi called Maudgalya. He had a terrible disease that made him cough and spit all day and covered his skin with scales and rashes. Still Nalayani served him as a devoted wife. Pleased with her unstinting service, the sage offered her a boon. Nalayani requested that he use his ascetic powers to indulge all her sexual desires. Accordingly, Maudgalya took the forms of many different men, some human, some divine, all handsome, and made love to her in many different ways. After indulging in sexual pleasures for many years, Maudgalya decided it was time to renounce the world. But Nalayani was not satisfied. ‘Who will make love to me after you are gone?’ she asked. Disgusted by her insatiable lust, the Rishi cursed her that in her next life she would be the wife of many men."
There are other interesting subplots too. Like how Shakuni was not wicked de novo and why he did the things that he did. What made him limp. How each of the Pandavas had multiple wifes and children and how each of them plays some part in the battle. How Krishna twisted so many rules and used his powers to help Pandavas win the war. How The Pandavas too lost everything at the end of it. How the epic doesn't end with the war , it ends with Yudhishtira realising the true meaning of dharma. And that's what the central theme of the epic is. How each action of every character is governed by their good or bad karma. How each of the so called good characters have bad traits which we never knew. And in the end why the Pandavas in spite of being the good people end up in Naraka and the Kauravas end up in Swarga.
All in all, it's a good book and more importantly the story of Mahabharata is something which each of us should read at least once. It won't change your spiritual thinking in any way but it would definitely make you proud about the knowledge and legacy of ancient Indians.
P.S. I read books once in a while, not that frequently, so these were just my amateur thoughts about this book. There might be better books and people who read often would better be able to tell more about the quality of the writing and it's accuracy. I personally like something which I can read uninterrupted without referring to my English dictionary frequently. Suggestions are always welcome.
PPS: Watch this guy talk about ancient Indian wisdom
Thanks to our larger brain, we can imagine and create a world where we can look beyond ourselves, include others, and make everyone feel wanted and safe. We can, if we wish to, establish a society where the mighty care for the meek, and where resources are made available to help even the unfit thrive. This is dharma.
Unfortunately, imagination can also amplify fear, and make us so territorial that we withhold resources, exploit the weak and eat even when well-fed. This is adharma. If dharma enables us to outgrow the beast in us, then adharma makes us worse than animals. If dharma takes us towards divinity, then adharma fuels the demonic.
The Kauravas are stubbornly territorial before the war. The Pandavas struggle to be generous after the war. Adharma is thus an eternal temptation, while dharma is an endless work in progress that validates our humanity."
These are words from the final chapter of the book on Mahabharata by Devdutt Pattanaik and they quite aptly sum up the essence of the book. Rather I should say that of the epic called Mahabharata. First a word about the author's contribution. He has managed to present the humongous piece of literature in a concise manner. The text is lucid and he has tried to simplify the confusing tangles of relationships. He keeps providing us short revisions everytime he reintroduces a character in subsequent chapters. And this comes in handy as remembering the lineage if each character is a pain. It's like the desi Game of Thrones. Everybody is related to everybody in some complex way and there are too many bodies there to remember. Plus there is karma which keeps coming back at intervals. So by the time it hits back at someone, you are way ahead in the story and recollecting the back story is difficult. He doesn't complicate things by showing off his vocabulary and keeps the language simple (I guess that's the only reason why Chetan Bhagat has such a following in India I guess. But I doubt whether he does that to hide his vocabulary or the lack of it). Plus that was the very reason the scriptures were written in Sanskrit so that only a small portion of the population could understand them. I don't know how accurate his version is but it's a book that can give you a gist of the story in the simplest possible way. There must be many other authentic translations but then as they say Devil is in the details. It would have been difficult for me to interpret all the plots and subplots if they were presented in a more complex manner. That's just my opinion though. He has also provided these small snippets at the end of each chapter giving us interesting facts and revising those complex subplots. Also even though it's labelled as an " illustrated retelling " , the illustrations don't serve much purpose
Coming to the more important part. The epic itself. I am otherwise an atheist and was sceptical about reading the Mahabharata. But then it's nowhere close to what I thought. It's not about gods and goddess. And to contrary to belief , it's not about the Kurukshetra war. That definitely forms an important part of the story but it's not the central theme. In fact it's a medium through which the central theme is elaborated i.e. Dharma and karma. And by dharma it never means blind faith and superstitions as projected by some of the present day " dharmik babas" . It means the righteous path, what is the ideal way of life. It's not that reading this has transformed me at a spiritual level , but does make you think about so many things. Keeping aside the spiritual part of it, it makes you aware of how awesome our forefathers were. Compiling such a huge book and carrying forward it's legacy through so many generation is a tremendous task. All this in the world without computers (They didn't have any of the cloud drive technology where they could back up their data at regular intervals. One hundred thousand verses over a span of 18 chapters). All the stories have such good morals and which are quite appropriate even in the Kaliyug. Plus their knowledge of astrology and other life sciences is fascinating. During the war there are these arrows which multiply as they travel. Some postulate that the ancient Indians were aware of nuclear weapons and this was an example of a nuclear fission reaction. I think that is a bit far fetched, but you never know. The other interesting part and the one that I liked that the actual stories are way different than what they have been presented to us. Why have always been told the story of how Kunti asked Arjuna to share Draupadi equally with his brothers but then there are other reasons to it too. Here it is :
"In her past life, Draupadi had invoked Shiva and asked for a husband who was honest, a husband who was strong, a husband who was skilled, a husband who was handsome and a husband who was knowledgeable. Shiva had said, ‘You will get all five men that you want for no single man, except God. In another past life, Draupadi was Nalayani, the wife of a Rishi called Maudgalya. He had a terrible disease that made him cough and spit all day and covered his skin with scales and rashes. Still Nalayani served him as a devoted wife. Pleased with her unstinting service, the sage offered her a boon. Nalayani requested that he use his ascetic powers to indulge all her sexual desires. Accordingly, Maudgalya took the forms of many different men, some human, some divine, all handsome, and made love to her in many different ways. After indulging in sexual pleasures for many years, Maudgalya decided it was time to renounce the world. But Nalayani was not satisfied. ‘Who will make love to me after you are gone?’ she asked. Disgusted by her insatiable lust, the Rishi cursed her that in her next life she would be the wife of many men."
There are other interesting subplots too. Like how Shakuni was not wicked de novo and why he did the things that he did. What made him limp. How each of the Pandavas had multiple wifes and children and how each of them plays some part in the battle. How Krishna twisted so many rules and used his powers to help Pandavas win the war. How The Pandavas too lost everything at the end of it. How the epic doesn't end with the war , it ends with Yudhishtira realising the true meaning of dharma. And that's what the central theme of the epic is. How each action of every character is governed by their good or bad karma. How each of the so called good characters have bad traits which we never knew. And in the end why the Pandavas in spite of being the good people end up in Naraka and the Kauravas end up in Swarga.
All in all, it's a good book and more importantly the story of Mahabharata is something which each of us should read at least once. It won't change your spiritual thinking in any way but it would definitely make you proud about the knowledge and legacy of ancient Indians.
P.S. I read books once in a while, not that frequently, so these were just my amateur thoughts about this book. There might be better books and people who read often would better be able to tell more about the quality of the writing and it's accuracy. I personally like something which I can read uninterrupted without referring to my English dictionary frequently. Suggestions are always welcome.
PPS: Watch this guy talk about ancient Indian wisdom
Kothaligad (aka Peth)!
6/19/2014 03:00:00 am
How to reach: There are two options. You can either go via Karjat (S.T from there to the base village, Ambivili) or from Neral ( There are those larger sized rickshaws aka "Tum Tums" ). We chose the Neral route. You have to get down on the other side of Matheran at Neral. We had already booked the rickshaws as we were nearly 100 people. Its better to start as early as possible
Here is a link if you want to know about the history : History
Base Village : Peth/ Ambivili
The route from Neral to Ambivili was surprisingly pleasant. The roads were excellent, most probably due to the pre-election constructions. Otherwise the one hour journey would have been a pain, especially when ten of you are stuffed in the Tum Tum (aka "Dukkar rickshaw")
Once at the base village there is a small hotel where we had refreshments and started the ascent.
This was our YHAI group. Please forgive my editing and (non-existent) photography skills. All pics have been captured on a humble 8 megapixel Note II camera.
The trek is otherwise easy but the monsoons hadn't set in. The three and half hour climb was hence a bit tiring due to the scorching heat. The same trek in the monsoon was a superb experience with multiple small waterfalls en route. Its always better NOT to carry your umbrellas/ rain coats , cause thats the best way to enjoy a monsoon trek. Trust me you will NEVER fall ill post a monsoon trek.
These are pics from this years trek
The difference if quite evident. The route is surrounded by lush green trees and waterfalls in the monsoon. Pics courtsey : TeamBHP.com
There are no difficult patches and even newbie can scale the peak quite easily. You can always take a guide from the base village. Once you reach the top there is a cave where we rested for a while and had our lunch. There are water tanks near the cave.
There is a spiral stairs which takes you to the top. The view from there is breath-taking. A large portion of the Western Ghats is see. The experienced trekkers could name all the peaks seen.
![]() |
| Finally there!!! |
The way down was easy as there path was dry. Had it rained it would have been slippery and that would have made things tough.
I would like to thank the YHAI group for organizing an excellent trek. The YHAI Ambernath consists of many senior trekkers who ensure safety of all the trekkers. The fees for the trek are also very very affordable. Here is the link for the website : YHAI Ambarnath HomePage. You can check the page for upcoming treks. I am not advertising them, but they are way better than the other hiking groups which charge anything in between 300 to 1000.
Click here for more pics:
More Pics....
Zabaan Sambhal Ke !!
4/25/2014 12:29:00 pm
“…are yeh toh kitna bada mass hai , iska biopsy toh aaram se
ho jayega.”
“Look at this dude, this is such a classic exam “CASE”
“Are yeh dekh isme kya superp De Musset's sign hai, kya
solid AR hoga isko”
“F!*# man, iski toh puri wat lag gayi hai.”
These
are a few of the common dialogues we have come across in our wards at the patient’s
bedside, failing to realize that the person lying in besides us is far more
than just an exam “CASE”.
For the
past six odd years I have spent (rather I should say the six years I have
“earned”) at this amazing place called KEM, I have said /heard/overheard many
things I shouldn’t have .The aforementioned statements top the list. It’s such
a common scenario at GS when such a rare/classic/ideal exam “CASE” gets
admitted in the war. The usual pathway being:
The tired medicine houseman “tries” to impress a
“sincere” second year female (who has no idea about it, but it is presented in
a way which makes it look important.) or an Intern (who knows everything about
the condition including the rarest of chromosomal mutation associated with it
and its effect on the prognosis, but doesn’t have the time to look at the case.
Thanks to the lame MCQ oriented CET, all he sees is how fast can he finish the
collection and head back to his bestest of friends “Amit ,Ashish and Mudit)
The ignorant second years gather around the case and the
houseman meticulously shows (-off) the “CASE”. After seeing such a classic/
rare case their enthusiasm knows no bounds. The entire class follows suit,
poking the patient (sorry am I supposed to call him the “CASE”?).And like every
news at the GS campus, even this one spreads like wild fire.
All
this time when those eager eyes are staring at the poor soul lying in the bed
is wondering why so many doctors are visiting him. He has a pseudo-notion that
“Itne bade bade dactar aa rahe hai tapas
karne ke liye ,ab hum toh zaaroor thik hoke jayenge”. Alas, none of this happens .None of the “bade bade dactars “ bother to strike a
communication with him or try to explain him what condition he has and what is
the treatment and what prognosis to expect. Forget about having a conversation
with the “CASE” most of us don’t even ask/ remember his name. He is popular and
referred to, not by his name but by his diagnosis-“The classic AR patient in
ward 4!” Everyone in the college knows his diagnosis, except him of course.
Out of
the innumerable patients that get admitted in our wards there will be very few
who will be aware of what disorder they have. Even if they are aware of what
their condition is called (thanks to the not too “soft spoken Ghasu” visitors
they cater to everyday), they have no clue about what it really means. There
was this one patient who was admitted in the ward for a bleeding gastric ulcer
.While wandering (that’s the most apt word to describe what we do in the wards
during our clinical postings) in the ward his relative showed us his endoscopy
report and asked us to explain me the same. We explained him whatever little we
knew (Our first posting in the wards just after finishing first year is the
only time we have the enthusiasm to do all such things). The patient’s relative
couldn’t stop praising us as no one had told them all these days what was wrong
(And then our ). The ignorant patient and his relatives deserve to know at
least this basic information. When we recruit patients for our research
projects, we are supposed to get an informed consent document signed from the
patient. Many a times it’s a misnomer ,its patient is neither informed , nor he
consents .Its just a document which the bade
dactar hands over and instructs “jaldi se yahan sign karo.”
Many a times we expect the patient to have
that rare diagnosis we suspect or that rare sign which we have just rattofied
from Harrison, for e.g. One of us had said during the emergency hours “Kash isko intracranial hemorrhage detect ho
CT pe. I have never diagnosed one before.” Do we fail to realize what the diagnosis
means to the patients?
You will find the most passionate students at
KEM, trying to “know” as much as possible. But few of us realize that for the
patient we are not someone who comes to learn and experiment on them, but to treat
them. I was a subject for a mock USMLE practical exam for one my friends and
was amazed at the protocol they follow abroad. You are supposed to introduce
yourself, explain the purpose of your visit and seek the patient’s permission
before you touch him. How many times have you seen that happening in the wards
here? I guess never. What we do is this “Are
yeh dekh, (holds the patients knee and knocks the hammer at the patients knees)
Kya mast knee jerk hai na!” .We are used to making remarks on the remarks
of the patient’s condition, often in colloquial terms like “Kitna bada lesion hai “. We never really
care how traumatic can this be for the already dampened morale of the patient. Try
conveying the prognosis of same to the patient. I bet you will be short of
words. Also how many times has it happened that while examining the patient we
indulge in some random conversation with our colleagues which is totally
unrelated to the patient? The worst part being is all this is happening in a
language the patient and his relatives understands. This conveys a wrong
message to the patient (and makes some more sensational news for the “research
team” of Satyamev Jayate.) The one thing we must learn from all senior
professors is the way they communicate with the patients in the OPD. The
argument against it being they see a lesser number of patients so they can
afford to spend so much time on each patient, but we can at least try to be as
polite as them. Its beneficial not only for the patient but for us too. Personal
experience says that if you have just talked to the patient before the procedure
and made him feel important, it makes things much easier if any untoward
complication arises if any.
I am no “ideal” student/doctor to go around preaching how you should behave with the patients .I have been indifferent to the patients’ suffering the same way as you presently are. I have cracked the silliest of jokes and laughed on them in the wards besides patients. But you tend to realise the humane side of being a doctor when you actually manage patients, when he is more than “just another exam CASE” for you. You realise it when you need to convey the most grievous of news to the patient’s relative and you are tongue-tied. Retrospectively thinking (which is always easier), learning these things seem far more important than the hours we spent in the library rattofying the rarest symptom of the rarest Zebra syndrome. And then we realise (again retrospectively) why the KEM motto so appropriately states: “Non sibi sed omnibus “- Not for self, but for all.
I am no “ideal” student/doctor to go around preaching how you should behave with the patients .I have been indifferent to the patients’ suffering the same way as you presently are. I have cracked the silliest of jokes and laughed on them in the wards besides patients. But you tend to realise the humane side of being a doctor when you actually manage patients, when he is more than “just another exam CASE” for you. You realise it when you need to convey the most grievous of news to the patient’s relative and you are tongue-tied. Retrospectively thinking (which is always easier), learning these things seem far more important than the hours we spent in the library rattofying the rarest symptom of the rarest Zebra syndrome. And then we realise (again retrospectively) why the KEM motto so appropriately states: “Non sibi sed omnibus “- Not for self, but for all.
So the next time you find that
interesting “CASE” try to curb thy enthusiasm ,at least in front of the patient
.Also when you are besides a “patient”(this sounds much more humane) ,avoid
discussing the latest movie in theatres or the hottest girl on campus. There’s
always the evergreen katta for these conversations!
From Daga to Haaga - One year down the line.......
7/01/2012 03:05:00 amAfter an extension of 2months our housemanship has finally ended. Thanks to the “stalwarts” conducting the “prestigious” CET’s we have had the” privilege” of working as a houseman for an extra 2months.Only a houseman knows how desperately he anticipates the arrival of the new batch (“365 aur 405 din housemanship karne ka difference tum kya jano ramesh babu”). We are now ready to hand over the baton of “huge responsibilities” to our “able” juniors!
So how does it feel to enter second
year PG? It feels great. However it just “feels” great, it isn’t that great. The
feeling of “I am done with all the mama work,
and all I have to do is quality work “is just too good (again it’s just a
feeling and not the truth!) .But as Peter Parker has taught us “With great
power comes great responsibility”, second year has its own woes. It’s
like having too much of responsibility with too less of power! First year flew
in no time and we were too busy rejuvenating ourselves after the CET
preparation that we didn’t FIND enough time to open our books (Retrospectively I
would say we never really SEARCH hard enough).First year is like an
extended honeymoon period. We are elated after clearing the swayamvar of the “prestigious “ CET (which is more
gruesome than the one with Rakhi)and getting “engaged” the seat of our choice.
So we bask in the glory, showing off our “prized catch” although only until the
tragedy called the second year strikes. We are suddenly expected to know
everything overnight and as we are still busy in our honeymoon, cuddling with
our darling; this comes as a harsh wake-up call which we can’t snooze. What
follows is a series of comments from our seniors and professors.”Itna bhi nahi ata “,”junior ko kya sikhayega”,”First
year mein kya kiya”(this last question haunts me now and I am still trying
to find an answer.) And all the above
comments (and ALL other comments too) come with a prefix of “Are ek saal ho gaya toh bhi-“.These
anguishes don’t end with the people above in the hierarchy, the juniors too
play a part in our misery. They are excited after their triumph and come up
with “we-must-know-by-the-end-of-one-year” types questions (exactly as we did
14 months ago).But we always have the ultimate escape route for such questions
, the “raamban ilaaj” which is being
used for years .As a senior, whenever you don’t know something you MUST know you
always have the option of saying “Kal
padhke bata .Read up and tell me tomorrow “.This works two ways either it
buys us time so that we can read up the same or we can just wait for the junior
to read up and enlighten us ,while we give the expression of “I knew it ,wanted
you to open your book. No spoon-feeding here.” During first year,“You are not
expected to know and you don’t know” ;Third year “ You are expected to know and
you know” ,unfortunately for second year “ You are expected and you don’t know”
But how does it feel to finish first
year? It not only feels great, it is. It was a fun filled ride. We are never “exposed”
to radiology as we are to Medicine and Surg. So when we prepare these two are
the broad categories we plan to do a PG in.To add to it ,getting radiology is not
the easiest of tasks so we can’t plan/boast of aspiring the same, especially
with the present pattern of our “prestigious” PGCET .It’s almost always the
second choice, atleast it was for me. After winning the swayamvar, it’s like the sexier and more elusive choice available,
which makes you ditch the Harrisons and Sabistons. And while Radiology eludes
you there are people who are skeptical about you choosing it. They try to
persuade/convince by claiming that it’s a non-clinic branch, no exposure to
patients etc. .Is it that way? I would say it all depends upon how clinical you
want it to be. You are supposed to know some clinical stuff from each branch,
be it Obstetrics, Medicine or Peds or Surg. The more you apply the clinical knowledge,
the radiology becomes much easier. Also you have always the option of
Intervention Radiology later. The thing that you miss is the work satisfaction
a surg/med housie gets when a patient thanks him after getting treated. But
remember we definitely played an important part by diagnosing the disorder in
the first place! Unlike the popular belief of “Radio people just sit in air-conditioned
rooms “, hum thoda toh kam definitely
karte hain yaar!
This one year has been a great learning experience,
though not academically but otherwise. Got the time to direct one of the best
Apurvai so far, have explored more places than what I did during my UG days and got hooked to reading books (other than those
purchased form Bhalani and National for a change).All said and done ,I am satisfied with
the decision made one year (sorry 14 months) ago.
P.S.
For all those who don’t know Daga is a book for PG preparation and Haaga is a
radiology book (The quest for a catchy title has made me come up with this.)Bhalani
and National are Medical book shops and Apurvai is our marathi college play.
P.P.S.
You may find many grammatical errors in the above and in ALL my previous and future other posts you
have the option of blaming Word’s spellcheck or my poor English. I prefer that
you be nice to me and choose the former!
What to do and what not to do- A guide to tackle the menace called PG Medical CET!!
4/14/2012 07:53:00 am
“Amit Ashish says that the
most common cause of the most common cause complication of renal failure in an
elderly population with type II Diabetes Mellitus is Infection”
OR
“Mudit says that the most
common tumour of the bone is …. While the most common benign tumour is …. , the
most common malignant tumour is …. And the most common lesion is ….
Hence we have to answer the
question according how the question is framed.”
OR
“Mr XYZ from ABC coaching
classes (which claims success is a habit for them) has said that if the same
question is asked in the State Entrance the answer to be written is xyz and if
its asked in AIIMS the answer is zyx and if its asked in the All India the
answer changes to yzx
These are few of the “Most Common” discussions
which happened last year at the Katta (alongside Edward) or in the canteen
during lunch. Our preferences had changed. Amit Ashish, Arvind Arora and Mudit
Khanna were the most discussed people on Campus. The passion with which one
argues about each one of them is amazing. These were our best friends,
Philosophers and Guides. Retrospectively all these questions, their
discussions, their “controversial answers” seem so inane.In fact the entire
process of Indian PG medical entrance is quite bizarre. The very concept
of mugging repeats questions and the lack of application based question creates
a huge bias towards the "repeater" batch.Also if we have a look at
some recent papers the questions seemed to be too tough for a PG entrance
standard.All said and done as they say, you have to be in the system to
beat in the system. Luckily enough we have managed to get through this
byzantine process. I would like to share a few of the things which worked for
me.
There are three kinds of
people preparing for CET (The fourth (wiser!) type has already opted for
USMLE):
The typical Ghasu who is
tensed about all the exam stuff,
The “Chilled” guy who
prefers the Katta over the Reading Room and
The third type who is
confused regarding which type he belongs to. This article is primarily for the
former, cause the latter two will find it really boring.
Where to Start:
The first and the foremost
thing is to set your preferences as early as possible- CET or USMLE. This is
because the approach to bot the exams is totally different. If you planning to
take the USMLE then you need to concentrate on research projects and other
stuff to glorify your CV. while if you are planning to prefer the CET then you
have to start scrutinizing every tiny bit of information from the point of view
of a MCQ .
When to start:
It is easy to
retrospectively to tell people what they should do because you yourself have
repented not doing the same when you were at their place. So here’s what I
feel:
First year:
It’s too early to start
studying from the MCQ point of view. First year doesn’t require much of
tweaking. We have just finished one long year of slogging for the CET. We are
unadulterated and tend to continue to study in the same way as we did earlier.
I think the one point you can do is develop a liking towards biochemistry. That
is one subject that gets boring sometimes and needs revision a number of times.
Second Year:
Second year is the year of
Change in all our lives. The AIIMS trip , college functions et al are
responsible for the adulteration of the Ghasu minds in second year!! Our
First Honeymoon Period! Unfortunately it comes at a very wrong time. We realised
the importance of the Second year subjects later. These subject bridge the gap
between the first year subjects of Anat-Physio-Biochem and the final year
subjects of Surg-Med and OBGY. During second year the main goal should be
reading Pharmac and Patho thoroughly. Reading Robbins is a must; especially the
General Pathology part of it. You can render the services of our beloved Harsh
Mohan for the systemic pathology because a large portion of it gets covered in
Medicine. Pharmac ,just like biochem needs a lot of revision.
Third Year:
The honeymoon continues.
This is the period when you should start preparing meticulously because there
is lot of free time. Read Park religiously or I should say try to read Park as
much as possible. They tend to ask a lot of questions on the first few chapters
and Biostatistics. ENT and Opthal carry relatively low weightage.
Final Year:
As you are reading the
regular subjects try to finish them from the MCQ point of view too. Try to
cover up at least Peds, OBGY Surgery and whatever from medicine you can. Try to
read as much as Harrison as you can.
Internship:
It’s the year everything
else HAS TO take a back seat. You have to look at it this way: It is this year
which is going to decide where you are going to be, what you are going to do;
not only for the next year, but for your entire life! When there is so much at
stake, I don’t think you have a reason for not giving your best shot. Each one
of you from GS has the capability to end up in the top 500 of India. It all
depends on how you are going to channelize your efforts for this one year.
Remember that a single MCQ that you get wrong, you are 5 marks behind your next
competitor and at least 50 ranks behind in the completion. This could mean
compromising on the subject of your choice or the city of your choice. Remember
that you are not only competing with the present batch but a batch of repeaters
who have all the time in the world to study.
So if you have never
studied from the MCQ point of view, don’t worry. Neither had we. So here are a
few Do’s and Don’ts
The Do's
1. Revise
2. Revise again
3. And again and again.
The format of the CET (at
least till last year) is such that it relies more on hard work and slogging and
little of it actually tests our intelligence. So try to revise stuff as much as
possible. It’s better to read 10 subjects thoroughly than to read all 20 of
them half-heartedly.
4. Plan your studies well
in advance.
When you are faced with the
challenge of finishing 20 subjects in a span of 1 year while doing internship
you need to do plan systematically well in advance how are you going to go
about it. Set your goals according to your limitations. Retrospective studying
is the best at this point of time. While reading a subject if you feel that you
are weak at one subtopic, it’s better to read it up from a standard textbook
rather than just mugging up. If possible try to read Lippincott’s Biochemistry
textbook and first few chapters from Robbins and tables from Harrison, it helps
a lot. Be selective in the subjects and the amount of time you allot to each.
Prioritize your subjects as follows:
2nd year subjects are the
MOST important ones. After that start with the Skin Anaesthesia Radiology and
Psychiatry. These are the subjects with the maximum cost-benefit ratio. Then
first year subjects followed by PSM then read the previous year’s papers. Final
year subjects are relatively fresh. So once you start solving the previous
papers you will realise what subjects you are weak at and later you can opt to
read those specific subjects only. The rest of the subjects are to be read
depending on how much time you get. Before you start any new subject, just ask
yourself whether you are going to get time to revise it before the exam. Start
reading the subject only if the answer to the above question is in the
affirmative. Otherwise it’s just waste of time.
5. Try to maximise the time
available to you.
“Internship mein padne ke
liye time kisike paas nahi hota hai,time NIKALNA padta hai” . And when I say
nikalna I mean it the legal way as there are MANY other ways too! Try carrying
small portable books/diaries so that you can just revise those nagging things
like which chromosome has the gene for which abnormality or the obnoxiously
long list of syndromes we are supposed to know or the even more obnoxious list
of Most Common things. Sometimes studying or even pretending to study can get
you a bit of a concession from a houseman too! If you travel a long way to
college, what you can do is try listening to podcasts every day. Google and you
will find loads of them for the MLE. Or you can just record some stuff and
revise it.
6. Keep your references
handy
Try to keep all the
standard books ready for reference. You can keep the digital copy in your cell
phones (Indians need no advice on how to get their hands on pirated material so
I have skipped the technical details).it helps a lot as you won’t be able to buy/carry
all the reference books.
The Donts
1. Controversies!!
As you will start preparing
you will encounter many of the so called controversial questions. You will end
up wasting lots of time trying to hunt down the answer on the net, in reference
books, discussing with friends/seniors (who are equally ignorant) ,each one
having his unique theories. If you don’t find an answer acceptable, look it up
in a standard reference book. If you are still not conviced, forget it. The all
India topper scores around 75% so even if you want to be the topper you have 40
questions which you can you go wrong. So the next time you are confused
regarding any such controversy, put that question in the 40 questions quota.
2. Mnemonics!!
These are double edged
swords. Towards the start of your preparation you will tend to make mnemonics
for each and every thing. The problem is that you will remember that the
mnemonic for the causes of anion gap acidosis is MUDPILES but you won’t be able
to recollect what the u or the e in the mnemonic stands for. So instead try to
develop your own correlations. For example they keep on asking what test is
used to detect DNA proteins and RNA. The South Indians devour Dosa therefore
Southern Blot – DNA, Western - Pizza –Protein, Northern Rice-RNA—sounds a bit
stupid but it’s great as long as it works.One of the best resources
for mnemonics can be found here
RxPG Mnemonics Database.
3. The” Kar Lenge
attitude”:
There are certain simple things
which can fetch easy marks in the exams. For example chromosomal abnormalities
or pathological markers or paediatric milestones. Our attitude is that we find
it too easy to read and keep it postponing only repenting later in the exam
when you end up getting confused –retinoblastoma-13q14 or 14q13!!!So it’s
better to sit down and finish these simple things once and for all and keep
revising.
4. “Agle saal rank
nikalenge” attitude.
If you think from the start
itself that you won’t be able to get a rank you have lost the battle before it
has begun. Irrespective of your capacity always try to maintain a positive
attitude, even if you don’t get a rank you will end up studying a lot if you
have this attitude. It’s just a defence mechanism to avoid stuff. If you
continue to have this attitude then you may not get a rank in the second
attempt too.
5. Finally once again-Don’t
underestimate the importance of Revision.
Remember –“Ek aag ka
dariya hai aur tair ke jaana hai!!!!!”
Best of Luck!!
P.S. I know not an
interesting first post, but this was what I was planning to write since a long
time. Nothing extravagant just a few tips which you might find helpful. If you
have already passed through this treacherous path of CET (lucky you!!) /
chosen the alternate one of USMLE (luckier you!!) then you can ignore this.
Those who plan to tread this way (obviously you being the most unlucky ones!!)
benefit.Drop in comments, questions and doubts if any.

.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)


.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)

















